Avalilação PREreview de From Fraud Signals to Audit Response: A Human–AI Decision Governance Framework for Explainable Financial Statement Fraud Risk Assessment
- Publicado
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.24269867
- Licença
- CC0 1.0
1. Does the introduction explain the objective of the research presented in the preprint?
Selection: Yes
Comments:
Reviewer: Julian Rodriguez, Jr., FRSA, MRes, M.ISRM | ORCID: 0009-0007-9332-0140
The introduction sets up the problem clearly and logically. It walks through how fraud detection evolved from basic financial ratios (Beneish, Dechow) to machine learning and explainable AI (XAI), and nails the core practical gap: getting a fraud score and a local explanation still does not tell an auditor how much to trust that explanation, how to document an override, or how much extra testing is justified. The three research questions and four contributions match that objective cleanly.
2. Are the methods well-suited for this research?
Selection: Neither appropriate nor inappropriate
Comments:
For a conceptual framework paper, pulling together audit standards, XAI reliability research, and human-factors literature makes sense, and keeping the scope focused specifically on financial statement fraud rather than generic AI governance is a smart choice.
Three brief refinements would strengthen the design:
Justify the six-layer structure: Briefly explain why these specific six layers—and this sequence—were chosen over alternative groupings.
Align the Layer 4 equation with earlier layers: The expected-utility formula relies directly on the raw model probability () without formally incorporating explanation assurance (Layer 2), epistemic risk (Rodriguez, 2026a), or professional judgment (Layer 3).
Add one worked example: Include a short, end-to-end case walkthrough (e.g., a revenue-recognition flag where SHAP and LIME conflict) to show how an engagement team moves through all six layers in practice.
3. Are the conclusions supported by the data?
Selection: Somewhat supported
Comments:
Because there is no empirical dataset here, the conclusions are conceptual arguments rather than tested results, and the author is upfront about that. The central takeaway—that XAI outputs have to be checked for stability and filtered through professional skepticism before changing audit procedures—is well backed by the cited literature on class-imbalance distortion and automation bias.
Two claims need tighter grounding:
Tie directly to specific ISA 240 / audit documentation rules: Instead of referencing ISA 240 (Revised) broadly, link Layers 2, 3, and 6 directly to concrete audit documentation and quality-control rules (such as how an engagement team documents contradictory evidence or escalates to specialists).
Account for hidden false negatives in Layer 6: The feedback loop assumes audit outcomes can recalibrate the model over time. In real audits, you immediately see false positives when extra testing turns up nothing, but missed frauds (false negatives) often stay hidden for years until a restatement or enforcement action. The paper should note how governance avoids building false confidence from missing labels.
4. Are the data presentations, including visualizations, well-suited to represent the data?
Selection: Somewhat appropriate and clear
Comments:
The summary tables—especially the breakdown of failure modes, empirical measures, and follow-on research designs—are practical and easy to scan.
A few quick cleanups would polish the presentation:
Introduce Figure 1 in the text before it appears, and make sure the placement of "human override" matches between the diagram (Layer 3) and the body text (Layer 6).
Fix duplicate variable symbols in the equations (for instance, using the same letter for both cost and context).
Clarify in the risk-response table that a "low" model fraud score never allows an auditor to skip mandatory baseline procedures required by auditing standards (like journal-entry testing).
5. How clearly do the authors discuss, explain, and interpret their findings and potential next steps for the research?
Selection: Somewhat clearly
Comments:
Breaking out separate takeaways for researchers, audit firms, regulators, and AI developers works well, and the proposed empirical tests give other researchers clear starting points.
Three additions would make the discussion much sharper:
Differentiate static financial-statement fraud from continuous transactional gating (KYC/KYT): Treating "financial fraud" solely through periodic financial-statement screening overlooks how global financial governance—including recent IMF and World Bank policy discussions shifting from static Know Your Customer (KYC) checks toward continuous Know Your Transaction (KYT) monitoring—relies on real-time human gating under high alert volume. Explicitly situating the framework's human-gating boundary within this broader shift toward continuous transaction-level scrutiny would strengthen its practical relevance.
Reframe over reliance through the "Zero-Defect Paradox" rather than cognitive bias alone: The manuscript frames overreliance and under reliance primarily as individual cognitive heuristics (citing Parasuraman & Riley, 1997; Skitka et al., 2000; Dietvorst et al., 2015). In high-stakes financial compliance and auditing, however, the breakdown of human gating is driven by institutional incentives—specifically the Zero-Defect Paradox and Systemic Intent Shadows (Rodriguez, 2026b, 2026c). When regulators impose zero-tolerance penalties for a single missed fraud while rarely penalizing false positives, practitioners face severe compliance latency and administrative paralysis: rational auditors rubber-stamp noisy AI flags ("defensive over-auditing") rather than risk regulatory second-guessing on a human override. Incorporating institutional inspection liability into Layer 5 and Layer 6 would make the governance model far more realistic.
Map the four types of validity to the six layers & add a 2026 comparison grid: Explicitly linking predictive, explanatory, professional, and decision validity across Layers 1–6—and adding a compact comparison table against the cited 2026 hybrid human–AI governance frameworks—would clarify the paper's distinct contribution at a glance.
References
Rodriguez, J., Jr. (2026a). An Analytic Grammar for Diagnosing Epistemic Risk in Generative AI. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22780948
Rodriguez, J., Jr. (2026b). The Zero-Defect Paradox: Systemic Lags, Administrative Paralysis, and Compliance Latency in Automated Risk Governance. FAIEMA 2026 / Zenodo.
Rodriguez, J., Jr. (2026c). The Brights in the Fog: How AI-Driven Compliance Amplifies Systemic Intent Shadows (SIS). SSRN / ResearchGate.
6. Is the preprint likely to advance academic knowledge?
Selection: Moderately likely
Comments:
Yes—it tackles a real operational bottleneck just as firms are deploying XAI tools and preparing for ISA 240 (Revised). Treating "explanation assurance" as a mandatory checkpoint before an auditor relies on an XAI output is a genuinely useful idea. Cleaning up the Layer 4 utility equation, situating human gating within broader KYC/KYT and regulatory inspection dynamics, and adding a worked forensic walkthrough will make this a solid reference for both researchers and audit teams.
7. Would it benefit from language editing?
Selection: No
Comments:
The writing is clear, well-structured, and uses auditing and XAI terminology accurately throughout.
8. Final Recommendation & Disclosures
Would you recommend this preprint to others? Yes, it's of high quality
Is it ready for attention from an editor, publisher or broader audience? Yes, after minor changes
Competing Interests: The author declares that they have no competing interests.
Competing interests
The author declares that they have no competing interests.
Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
The author declares that they used generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.