Ir para o conteúdo principal

Escrever um comentário

Avalilação PREreview Estruturada de From Fraud Signals to Audit Response: A Human–AI Decision Governance Framework for Explainable Financial Statement Fraud Risk Assessment

Publicado
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24244231
Licença
CC BY 4.0
Does the introduction explain the objective of the research presented in the preprint?
Yes
The introduction explains the objective clearly and in a logical order. 1. It first describes the background and the fact that fraud detection has moved from statistical models to machine learning, explainable AI (XAI), and decision-oriented evaluation (pp. 1–2). 2. It then names the problem. A fraud score with an explanation does not tell the auditor what to do next. The paper calls this the “prediction–decision–governance gap” (p. 2). 3. It states the aim directly, which is to develop a Human–AI Decision Governance Framework for fraud risk assessment. 4. It lists three research questions and four contributions.
Are the methods well-suited for this research?
Neither appropriate nor inappropriate
This is a conceptual paper, so the methods section draws from existing literature and no data, sample, or statistical analysis is involved. What works well: 1. A conceptual design fits the aim of the paper, which is to connect several separate research areas and to propose ideas for later testing. 2. The paper follows a recognized approach for conceptual articles as recommended by Jaakkola (2020). 3. The author states openly that the literature was selected for a specific purpose and that the paper is not a systematic review. This honesty is good practice. 4. The author explicitly states boundary conditions, so readers know where the framework applies. What to Improve: 1. The steps from the literature to the six layers are described only briefly. The paper does not explain why there are six layers, why they are in this order, or what other designs were considered. 2. The equations do not match the framework. The decision formula uses only the model probability and leaves out explanation assurance and professional judgment: The expected-utility formula in Layer 4 uses only the model probability pᵢ. Explanation assurance (EAᵢ, Layer 2) and professional judgment (Jᵢ, Layer 3) do not appear in it. The formula therefore goes directly from probability to action. This is exactly the shortcut that the paper argues against, and it does not agree with the paper’s own statement, which asserts that “pᵢ ≠ audit action” (p. 9 of the draft). 3. The literature review for RQ1 is short and selective. It gives much weight to two studies from one country and does not cover text-based fraud detection. 4. There is no worked example and no expert feedback to show that the framework can be applied. The overall scholarly contribution of this conceptual paper would be even more significant if the revision documents how the framework was derived, aligns the equations with the text, and adds a worked example.
Are the conclusions supported by the data?
Somewhat supported
The paper has no empirical data, so the question is whether the conclusions follow from the literature and the argument. What is well supported: 1. The main conclusion is that an AI prediction is an input to professional judgment and not a replacement for it. This follows from the cited research on automation misuse, algorithm aversion, and professional skepticism. 2. The conclusion that an explanation is not automatically reliable is supported by the cited systematic review of fraud-XAI studies. 3. The paper is careful in its wording. It states that the propositions are not tested and that the framework still requires empirical validation. It does not report effects that were not observed. Where the conclusions go further than the paper shows: 1. The paper states that it is built on ISA 240 (Revised). However, it discusses the standard only in general terms. No specific requirement is cited or connected to a layer. 2. The conclusion that feedback from audit outcomes can improve the system assumes that fraud outcomes can be observed. In practice, only detected fraud becomes known. Missed fraud usually stays unknown.
Are the data presentations, including visualizations, well-suited to represent the data?
Somewhat appropriate and clear
The paper contains no data. Its presentations are one figure and five tables that summarize ideas. What works well: 1. Table 1 gives a clear overview of the six stages of fraud assessment research. 2. Table 3 is especially useful. For each concept it gives a definition, a typical failure and a possible measure for future studies. 3. Tables 4 and 5 link each proposition to a suitable research design, which will help other researchers. 4. Figure 1 is simple and easy to read. The feedback arrow shows the lifecycle idea well. 5. Table 2 is correctly labelled as an illustration and not as a fixed rule. What should be improved: 1. Figure 1 is not mentioned anywhere in the main text, and it appears before the section that explains it. 2. The title of Figure 1 differs slightly from the framework name used in the text. The figure also places “human override” in Layer 3, while the text discusses it in Layer 6. 3. Table 1 has no citations for its stages. 4. Table 2 suggests that low risk needs only routine procedures. This should be checked against procedures that auditing standards require in every audit. 5. Some symbols are used twice. For example, C means both cost and context.
How clearly do the authors discuss, explain, and interpret their findings and potential next steps for the research?
Somewhat clearly
What is clear: 1. The implications are organized for four groups of readers, including researchers, auditors and audit firms, regulators and standard setters, and AI developers. Each group receives specific points. 2. The limitations are stated honestly. The paper says the framework is not validated and that no universal threshold is proposed. 3. The next steps are concrete. Table 5 gives a research question, a design, a comparison and an outcome for each proposition. What is less clear: 1. The four types of validity are presented as a main contribution, but they are not connected to the six layers. 2. The next steps do not address how fraud outcomes will be observed, although the proposed field studies depend on this.
Is the preprint likely to advance academic knowledge?
Moderately likely
Reasons for a positive view: 1. The research question is important and timely, because audit firms are adopting AI tools and a revised fraud standard is coming into effect. 2. The idea of checking the reliability of an explanation before an auditor relies on it is useful and can be studied in experiments. 3. The link between decision thresholds and graded audit responses connects two research areas that are usually separate. 4. The research agenda gives other researchers clear starting points. Reasons for the rating: 1. The author claims that several 2026 frameworks have already narrowed the gap. Most of the six layers have close relatives in that work, and the paper does not yet show the difference in a direct comparison.A comparison table would address this concern. The earlier frameworks could be placed in the rows and the framework elements in the columns, with marks showing what each one covers. 2. The two most original ideas are stated but not developed in detail. These are: (a) explanation assurance as a check before reliance, and (b) the link from decision utility to graded audit responses. These two ideas are the strongest material in the paper. 3. No empirical evidence or worked example is provided, so the practical value of the framework is not yet shown.
Would it benefit from language editing?
No
The English is clear, fluent and consistent. Sentences are well formed and technical terms are used correctly. Professional language editing is not needed.
Would you recommend this preprint to others?
Yes, it’s of high quality
Is it ready for attention from an editor, publisher or broader audience?
Yes, after minor changes

Competing interests

The author declares that they have no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The author declares that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.

Você pode escrever um comentário nesta Avaliação PREreview de From Fraud Signals to Audit Response: A Human–AI Decision Governance Framework for Explainable Financial Statement Fraud Risk Assessment.

Antes de começar

We will ask you to log in with your ORCID iD. If you don’t have an iD, you can create one.

What is an ORCID iD?

An ORCID iD is a unique identifier that distinguishes you from everyone with the same or similar name.

Começar agora