Ir para o conteúdo principal

Escrever uma avaliação PREreview

Electrical Properties of Human Tissues and Cells: From Membrane Potential to Systemic Electrophysiology

Publicado
Servidor
Zenodo
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22986672

Version 1.10 (27 September 2026) — the first version since 1.7 to add scientific content, and the largest single addition in this manuscript's history. No value, interval, figure, evidence grading or conclusion carried by version 1.9 is altered.

What was added. Section 4.2 supplies a specified, repeatable search for absolute resting membrane potentials of human non-excitable cells, and reports its result: five relevant studies, every human one reporting the depolarisation comparatively rather than as a value, none giving an absolute figure at the abstract-level record this review verifies at, and the only absolute resting potentials found being canine. Sections 4 and 4.1 had carried no parameter value at all for nine versions, resting on a statement that had never been tested by a stated search. Four rows now join Table 1, three of them a well-specified human induced-pluripotent-stem-cell dataset and one a canine pair labelled as canine.

Section 5.6 and Table 3. The compilation this review relies on for human tissue resistivity publishes, for every value, the number of primary sources and the number of individual measurements behind it. Thirteen of its twenty-one rows rest on a single primary source and seven on two measurements. This review had used those two columns for one row only. Table 3 reproduces the complete published table with its evidential base, ordered by number of primary sources rather than alphabetically, so the thinness is visible at a glance.

Sections 7.3 and 7.4, and Table 4. Earlier versions described what bioimpedance estimates and never the electrical quantities it measures. Table 4 gives sex-specific specific resistivity, reactivity, impedance and phase angle in 265 men and 295 women aged 65 to 100, measured at 50 kHz and 800 microamps, together with the measured age dependence in 201 adults aged 60 to 89. Section 7.4 records the study that re-measured the thirty-year-old adult bioimpedance vector reference on 4,367 adults and found the reference vectors significantly displaced, for a reason stated in the original work: the adult reference had been built by pooling underage, adult and elderly subjects. No measurement error is involved anywhere in that case, which is why it is in this paper.

Section 7.5. Electrical impedance tomography, the clinical technology that consumes this review's conductivity tables as model coefficients, and which no earlier version mentioned. Organ conductivities are assumed known a priori in the EIT inverse problem; the consensus reconstruction algorithm publishes its figures of merit in rank order with high resolution last and noise amplification and electrode-movement sensitivity as binding constraints; and the evaluation standard was later rebuilt on 2,759 pairs of real lung shapes segmented from human CT rather than on point distributions.

Section 10.1. The minimum specification for quoting a parameter gains the two conditions that sections 5.6 and 7.4 identified and that the list had omitted while the review was already demanding conditions of others: the evidential base a value rests on, and, for a value used as a normative reference, the composition and date of the sample it was drawn from.

What was corrected. The related-work declaration described the companion physical-energy review as unsubmitted and not under review, and said a corrected version was in preparation. It was resubmitted to IEEE Reviews in Biomedical Engineering on 26 September 2026 under its retained manuscript number, so all three statements were false when read. The row now gives the full sequence and states that no reviewer has seen any version of it.

The sex-and-gender statement said that none of this manuscript's measured human values carried a sex distribution. Table 4 does, because its source published it that way. The statement is rewritten, the remaining absence is scoped to the tissue- and cell-level tables, and the contrast between them is named as the finding: whole-body bioimpedance reports sex as a matter of course while tissue-level electrical measurement largely does not.

The quantified overlap with the companion framework manuscript moved from 36 of 46 cited sources (78%) to 36 of 56 (64%) as references were added. The numerator is unchanged: the companion cites none of the ten new sources. The figure went stale three times during this revision and was caught by script on each occasion rather than by a reader, which is what that script exists for.

Two table-numbering faults and two false universal statements were introduced during the revision and found before the build was accepted. Each is itemised in section 11.15 together with the sentence that was wrong, rather than corrected silently.

What did not change. No value, interval, table entry, figure, reference, evidence grading or conclusion carried by version 1.9. Table 2 and Figure 3 are unchanged and the cell-by-cell check between them still passes. References 46 to 56; tables 4 to 5. Preflight on this version: 0 FAIL, 0 WARN, and all thirteen programme checks pass. The change log is section 11.15. The scientific gate is unchanged at YELLOW.

Version 1.9 (25 September 2026) — two corrections, both about other documents rather than about this one's science.

First, this manuscript said twice that its companion framework paper was unpublished. Section 1.2 and the Related work declaration both stated that the companion manuscript — Bioelectrical Parameters of Living Systems: A Scientific Framework for Understanding Voltage, Current, Frequency and Biological Function — was unpublished and carried no identifier. It was published on 22 September 2026 under Zenodo concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22829923. Both sentences were true when written and false by the end of the day of that deposit, and neither was updated. Both now cite the companion by its concept DOI.

Second, the related-work disclosure named one related deposit where there are five. It now lists all five of the author's deposited works on adjacent subject matter, each by concept DOI, together with two further public deposits that are disclosed and deliberately not cited — a manufacturer-published educational article and a patent register. One of the five, a PRISMA-ScR scoping review of reported stimulation parameters, discusses the author's own granted patent family as a documentary example; the declaration says so explicitly rather than leaving it to be discovered by following a citation.

No value, table entry, figure, reference, grading or conclusion changes. A whitespace-normalised diff of version 1.8 against version 1.9 yields 37 changed lines arising from four removed lines; every numeral in the removed text is present in the added text, and no reference entry or numeric table row is touched. The figures were regenerated at a minimum type size of 8.1 pt so that they clear an 8 pt floor once placed; no plotted value changed, and the figure is checked against its table mechanically.

The change log is §11.14. The scientific gate is unchanged at YELLOW.

Version 1.8 (22 September 2026). Eight corrections. No value, table entry, evidence grading or conclusion changes. What changes is what the manuscript says about its own completeness, one figure, one fraction, and one description of an earlier edit.

Version 1.7 closed this manuscript’s last evidence gap and left four places still saying it was open. The 95% confidence intervals of [B06] went into Table 2; the abstract, the paragraph printed directly beneath that table, and the caption of Figure 3 all continued to state that the intervals could not be obtained — and Figure 3 itself was still drawn without them. For a review whose argument is that parameters are quoted without the uncertainty that attached to them at measurement, a figure omitting uncertainty its own manuscript was holding is the failure the review exists to warn against.

Figure 3 is redrawn from the Table 2 rows: nine rows, each with its 95% confidence interval; cortical and cancellous tibia drawn separately because the source reports them separately and they differ by a factor of 38; and the source’s further row labelled simply “bone” (124 × 106 Ω·cm, four decades off scale) given in the note rather than plotted. A check now fails if the figure’s values and Table 2 ever diverge.

A finding came out of the repair. With the intervals drawn, the six soft-tissue rows whose means the source’s analysis of covariance declines to distinguish are seen not all to overlap: eight of the fifteen pairs are disjoint, separating lung, skeletal muscle, cardiac muscle and kidney from liver and spleen. This is not a contradiction — marginal intervals are not a hypothesis test, a covariate-adjusted ANCOVA may legitimately differ, and the source reports both without reconciling them. But this review’s standing complaint is that the ANCOVA finding is dropped whenever that table is cited, and quoting it while suppressing what the intervals show would be the same error reversed. It is now in §5.2 and on the figure. It was invisible for as long as the figure had no error bars.

The redundant-publication declaration’s denominator was stale. “36 of this paper’s 44 cited sources (82%)” was exact at version 1.6; two references were added at version 1.7 and the denominator was not recomputed. It is 36 of 46 (78%). The companion manuscript cites neither new reference, so the numerator is unchanged. Both figures are now re-measured from the two reference lists by script rather than by intention: a quantified disclosure carries a maintenance obligation that a vague one does not.

One earlier change log described an edit it had not made. Version 1.6’s bone row read “> 17,583 Ω·cm”, a lower bound; version 1.7 rewrote it as 17,583 Ω·cm with a 95% CI of 12,289–25,157, a mean with an interval, and recorded only the relabelling. The digits did not change and the assertion did. The rewrite is correct — the “greater than” was this review’s own unsourced artefact, carried since version 1.0 — and the description of it was not.

The check that should have caught these could not see the section they were recorded in. Version 1.7 carried its largest change log after the reference list, and the pre-submission checker reads only the text preceding it. Four universal self-claims in that section were never surfaced, and version 1.7 passed with no failures over a manuscript one whole section of which the checker had not read. Those sections are moved to their numeric place, and the checker now fails any manuscript carrying a heading after the references. A passing check must state what it read.

Você pode escrever uma avaliação PREreview de Electrical Properties of Human Tissues and Cells: From Membrane Potential to Systemic Electrophysiology. Uma avaliação PREreview é uma avaliação de um preprint e pode variar de algumas frases a um parecer extenso, semelhante a um parecer de revisão por pares realizado por periódicos.

Antes de começar

We will ask you to log in with your ORCID iD. If you don’t have an iD, you can create one.

What is an ORCID iD?

An ORCID iD is a unique identifier that distinguishes you from everyone with the same or similar name.

Começar agora