Aller directement à la PREreview

PREreview de Immune surveillance at plasmodesmata restricts the movement of a fungal effector

Publié
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24333758
Licence
CC BY 4.0

During a screen for Colletotrichum effectors targeting plasmodesmata, the authors discovered ChEC108 as a plasmodesmata-localised effector. Through different heterologous expression systems, the authors verify that ChEC108 is located at the plasmodesmata and is cell to cell mobile. Strikingly, its deletion actually increased pathogen virulence, suggesting that ChEC108 may activate plant immunity. To identify how, the authors turned to Co-IP, which revealed that ChEC108 binds the HMA-containing protein HIPP6. Through multiple approaches the authors show that the effector binds the HMA domains of the HIPP6 protein and that the binding leads to plasmodesmata closure and defence gene activation. Notably, this effect appears to be Arabidopsis-specific, which the authors link to differences between AtHIPP6 and NbHIPP6 variants. Together, these findings lead them to propose a model in which ChEC108 moves between cells via plasmodesmata during infection, but is stopped in Arabidopsis when it is bound by HIPP6 leading to closure of plasmodesmata and activating defence, proposing that HIPP6 functions as a plasmodesmata surveillance system in A. thaliana.

Callose deposition at plasmodesmata following pathogen recognition has long been recognized as a plant defense response. Although fungal chitin has been reported to trigger this response, the involvement of specific fungal effectors and their host targets in regulating this response remains poorly understood. This story provides compelling evidence for a fungal effector-host protein interaction that promotes plasmodesmal closure and restricts cell-to-cell movement, offering new insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying plasmodesmata-mediated plant immunity.

Additionally, this paper gives a great example of how plants use HMA domains to detect and bind pathogen effectors, adding an important piece to our understanding of plasmodesmata-based immunity.

We very much enjoyed reading this manuscript. Its writing is easy to understand and the manuscript shows a compelling story, giving us further insight into the complex interactions between plants and pathogens. With the following comments, we want to provide useful feedback. That said we want to emphasise that this story is of very high quality and we hope these suggestions could potentially help to further strengthen the publication.

Comments

A brief overview of the known functions of HIPPs in plant physiology and immunity would provide valuable context for readers and strengthen the manuscript.

Most experiments rely on heterologous systems, so including expression data for ChEC108 across infection stages would be a nice addition. As it’s part of the ChEC, I assume it is expressed during infection, but stating this explicitly would be helpful.

The authors draw a nice parallel to Magnaporthe Pwl2 in the discussion. Adding a brief note on the conservation of ChEC108 would complement this nicely. Given that the structure was solved, a structural similarity search against known effectors could also be interesting as similar analyses in MAX effectors have been valuable in placing these effectors in a wider context. It would also be worth clarifying whether ChEC108 is present as a single copy in the C. higginsianum genome.

The authors investigate the functional divergence of AtHIPP6 and NbHIPP6 by expressing AtHIPP6 in N. benthamiana together with the effector, which leads to reduced effector mobility, suggesting AtHIPP6 can restrict plasmodesmata transport in N. benthamiana. It would be interesting to know whether this effect is due to plasmodesmata closure or simply direct binding sequestering the effector. An approach similar to Figure S14, for example by complementation of the A. thaliana hipp6-3 mutant with the NbHIPP6, could help distinguish between these possibilities and would add a nice functional dimension to this part of the story.

The differential binding specificity of ChEC108 to various HMA domains (Figure S12) is an interesting finding that hints at potential binding specificity and functional diversity among HIPP proteins. A broader discussion of what these differences might mean biologically, and the consequences of ChEC108 interacting with different HIPPs, could be a valuable addition to the manuscript.

O’Connell et al. (2004) demonstrated that C. higginsianum uses secondary hyphae to infect adjacent cells. The results shown in Fig. 1D are consistent with this finding. However, further discussion of the increased abundance of biotrophic hyphae in ΔChEC108 (Fig. 1C) would be appreciated, as this observation seems counterintuitive.

Additional thoughts or suggestions we had while discussing the paper, but might be beyond the scope of this story:

It remains unclear how HIPP6 mediates plasmodesmata closure, specifically whether it acts directly at the plasmodesmata or whether it first signals to the nucleus to trigger closure. Measuring plasmodesmal size in the hipp6-3 mutant would be an interesting approach to further characterize the closure mechanism and the role of HIPP6 in this process.

Additionally, it would be interesting to further illuminate the role of callose for the observed plasmodesmata closure. Here experiments in the cals mutant defective in plasmodesmal callose deposition could help determine whether the HIPP6-mediated restriction depends on callose-mediated plasmodesmata closure or involves a different mechanism.

It would be interesting to determine how many cells are affected by plasmodesmata closure, as this would clarify whether the effect is locally restricted or spreads more broadly through the tissue.

The authors have shown that when ChEC108 does not bind HIPP6, it still localizes strongly at plasmodesmata and can additionally be found in the nuclei of adjacent cells. The lack of distinct induced DEGs upon ChEC108 expression is particularly interesting and could hint at a role in broader transcriptional suppression or even DNA degradation. Examining downregulated genes more closely could provide further hints in this direction, and this would certainly make for an exciting future study.

While ChEC108 appears to activate plant immunity when expressed in planta, this does not seem to translate into a strong immune response during infection, yet deletion of the effector leads to stronger disease symptoms. It would be interesting to understand what underlies this intriguing observation.

The authors conclude that ChEC108 binding to HIPP6 promotes plasmodesmal closure, compromising cell-to-cell communication and affecting multiple cellular processes. While this is an interesting interpretation, the causal link between reduced cell-to-cell communication and the observed growth phenotypes is not directly shown, and a contribution of growth-immunity tradeoffs cannot be excluded. Whether these two processes act independently or interact would be an interesting question to explore.

Minor comments

The authors describe ChEC108 as having been identified during the screen from Ohtsu et al. (2024), however ChEC108 is not mentioned in that study. The authors could clarify this point to avoid confusion.

Throughout the manuscript, in planta is italicised while in vitro and in vivo are not. For consistency, all three should be treated the same way.

Figs. 4D and 4E: Specifying which signals are detected in these panels would help readers better understand the results.

Overall this is a well-executed study and we look forward to seeing it published.

Conflict of interest

None

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The authors declare that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.