Commentaires
Écrire un commentaireAucun commentaire n’a encore été publié.
Overall Assessment:
The importance of energy-dependent quenching (qE) has been well established in many C3 crops but whether qE plays a similar role in C4 plants has largely been unexplored. The authors generated null PsbS alleles in the C4 grass Setaria viridis and confirm that these mutants lack qE. They show that psbS mutants have a greater loss of PSII efficiency in high light and reduced CO2 assimilation. Despite this, aboveground dry biomass and growth rate under fluctuating light are unaffected in S. viridis psbS and the authors assert that qE is not of significant benefit in Setaria viridis or C4 crops under fluctuating light. They propose that C4 plants prioritize PSI protection over qE/PSII due to the greater energy demand of C4 plants that is typically met by increased cyclic electron flow around PSI.
Overall, I consider this an important study. The evidence supports the conclusions for S. viridis but provides less support for the broader claims regarding C4 adaptation. The methods are appropriate; two independent null alleles were isolated and characterized by several approaches. This work addresses a genuine knowledge gap of the role of PsbS-dependent qE in C4 plants. However, the central conclusion that qE does not have an adaptive advantage to C4 plants is currently broader than the evidence can support. This work is a valuable contribution to our understanding of photoprotection in C4 species: it is the first psbS mutant in a C4 species to my knowledge and it suggests that we need further exploration of the importance of qE in C4 crops in which there are many efforts to engineer photosynthesis.
Major Points:
1. The authors conclude that “unlike in C3 plants, qE does not provide a significant adaptive advantage to C4 plants under dynamic light conditions” (lines 32-33). However, C3 and C4 plants were not compared directly and only one C4 species was tested. The authors may consider framing the conclusion as specific to Setaria viridis under the conditions tested. The larger C3/C4 claim would be supported further with testing an existing C3 psbS mutant side-by-side with the S. viridis psbS lines: Arabidopsis npq4 and rice psbS knockout lines have been previously published, and testing multiple species directly would strengthen the claims.
2. The aboveground dry biomass and relative growth rate of the psbS mutants did not differ from WT in fluctuating light (Fig. 4b,c). Arabidopsis npq4 mutants show a similar result, with fluctuating light having little effect on vegetative growth but a large effect on seed production (Külheim et al., 2002; Külheim and Jansson, 2005). The authors cite these studies as evidence that qE is important in C3 plants (lines 49-51). The authors may consider measuring seed yield in the S. viridis psbS lines grown under fluctuating light. Since the comparison with the C3 species relies on seed production, this would allow a more direct comparison with the C3 studies and test whether qE confers a reproductive advantage.
3. The descriptions of CO2 assimilation in the text have inconsistencies. The text states that “the lack of qE had little effect on instantaneous responses of net CO2 assimilation rates to fluctuating light” (lines 96-98) but Fig. 3a shows lower A in psbS-2 than in WT during the three high light phases. The text (line 121) later says there is “decreased CO2 assimilation under high light and during the high light phases of fluctuating light” which is reflected in the data. Clarifying these points would make the central claim more consistent.
Minor Points:
1. The text itself references previous work that has linked qE to field performance in several C4 crops (ref. 46-48) and PsbS has been shown to be important for maize acclimation to extended high light (ref. 45). Setaria and Sorghum-Maize evolved C4 NADP-ME photosynthesis independently separated by 25+ million years, which may have influenced the relative importance of qE in these species. Additional psbS mutants in C4 lines, specifically Sorghum or Maize, would provide additional support for a claim on C4 adaptive benefit as a future direction.
2. In Fig. 2c the de-epoxidation state is reported as Z/(Z+V) without antheraxanthin in the standard ratio (Z+0.5A)/(V+A+Z). The authors can provide an explanation for why antheraxanthin was excluded in the methods section or consider including antheraxanthin in the DES calculation.
3. The authors say that biomass is “identical” between WT and psbS-2 in Fig. 4b but the psbS-2 biomass is numerically slightly higher, although not significant with an n=6-7. Rephrasing as “not significantly different” may be more consistent with the current data. Repeating the experiment with a higher number of biological replicates or with a tissue-culture WT control (if there is some effect of tissue-culture process on the plants) may better resolve whether the WT and psbS-2 lines are identical.
4. In Fig. S7 NDH mutant plants are shown relative to WT but the image only shows the ndhO-2 plants without the WT controls. The image seems to show yellow/white leaves but this could also result from a glare. Including WT plants side-by-side with the ndhO-2 mutant plants would help readers interpret the phenotype.
5. The Fig. 2 and Fig. 3a figure legends cite psbS-1 and psbS-2 but the figure only shows psbS-2. Revising the figure legend to reflect the figure here can improve clarity.
6. The text and figure legends refer to the mutants as psbS while the figures use psbs. Consistency with figures/text would aid overall clarity of the manuscript.
I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor. I am a postdoc working in photoprotection optimization in C3 and C4 crop species.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
The authors declare that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.
Aucun commentaire n’a encore été publié.