Blockchain technology has evolved beyond financial transactions to revolutionize trust systems. This paper presents a blockchain-based model for decentralized rental agreements and dispute resolution (DRADR). By leveraging smart contracts and implementing two distinct arbitration approaches, our model offers flexible solutions for rental agreement automation, transparency enhancement, and impartial dispute resolution. Our study provides a comprehensive technical analysis of both approaches through theoretical frameworks, smart contract implementation, game-theoretic modeling, and comparative evaluation across multiple legal jurisdictions. We explore the potential of blockchain technology to address long-standing challenges in traditional rental systems, such as power imbalances, inefficiencies, and legal disputes. Key contributions include the integration of decentralized and local justice systems, detailed game-theoretic analysis of strategic behaviors, and comparative insights into gas efficiency, economic viability, and jurisdictional adaptability across both arbitration approaches. This research paves the way for a more equitable and transparent rental market and contributes to the broader acceptance of blockchain-based solutions in everyday transactions.