Saltar a PREreview

PREreview del Revealing the spatiotemporal dynamics of methionine metabolism with a genetically encoded single-fluorophore biosensor

Publicado
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24427356
Licencia
CC BY 4.0

Overall assessment:

Currently available methionine biosensors are FRET based which have limitations such as having a narrow dynamic range and pH sensitivity among others. Cohen et al. have created a biosensor that has a high dynamic range with low pH sensitivity that can be used in multiple cell lines. This research resulted in a new, more broadly applicable biosensor. However, the in vivo application would be more convincing with a few additional experiments, described below.

The authors make three main claims. First, the subcellular uptake of methionine was measured in multiple cell lines in multiple cell locations. This is an important claim since methionine has mainly been measured in the cytoplasm of non-mammalian cells. The tests performed using Meteor and MeteorITE strongly support these conclusions. Second, they state that the dynamics of the methionine cycle can be measured in the cytoplasm and nucleus. However, Meteor reports methionine concentration only, so the current evidence does not fully support this claim. Methionine levels are one readout of the cycle and cannot resolve flux through the cycle or the activity of its enzymes. Lastly, the claim that Meteor can be used to visualize methionine dynamics in vivo can be further supported by the addition of negative controls like MeteorITE. Without these controls it is unclear whether the detection of Meteor is specific.

Overall, this work is novel in providing a genetically encoded methionine biosensor that functions in mammalian cells. Adding negative controls for the experiments tracking methionine concentration in vivo and changing the language regarding the measuring the methionine cycle with these biosensors would increase the accessibility of this paper.

Major Comments:

1. Figure 1Panel e, it would be helpful to show that MeteorITE folds properly in the cell after all the mutations. This would help confirm that it works as a true negative control meaning it does not bind methionine but is otherwise intact. Computational/structural prediction methods may be helpful in showing this point. If resources are limited, authors could instead acknowledge these limitations in the results section.

2. Figure 5 shows that homocysteine converts into methionine and that the methionine concentration can be measured. However, this does not reflect the dynamics of the whole methionine cycle. The methionine cycle is made up of four steps and in this paper the focus is on the conversion from homocysteine to methionine which is only one step from the whole cycle. The authors could either add experiments addressing other parts of the cycle or adjust the wording to refer to methionine concentration rather than the cycle. This would make the Meteor limitations easier for readers to understand.

3. The Meteor fluorescence in Figure 6 would be more convincing if the same controls used in the cell-based experiments (Figures 1-5) were included. Showing these negative controls would convince the reader that the Meteor fluorescence is a specific response to methionine and not a result of nonspecific effects. Some suggestions for experiments include: 1) showing that MeteorITE fluoresce does not change in response to methionine 2) fluorescence is specific to methionine by testing one other amino acid 3) fluorescence is dependent on the concentration of methionine or 4) that methionine can be produced from homocysteine.

Minor Comments:

4. Page 5 line 12 the term “good dynamic range” is used. It may be helpful for others not in the field, to mention and compare to Meteor the dynamic range of multiple biosensors so that the reader has an understanding for what a good dynamic range can be.

5. Page 6 line 8 reads “reaching a maximum response around 32 mM methionine” the 32 mM may be a typo for 32 µM.

6. Figure 2 panel a would be easier to read if different colors were used for every concentration rather than a gradient of the same color.

7. The Figure 2 panel a order in the legend (left, middle, right) does not match the graphs. The y-axis labels show the first graph as 560 nm emission, the second as 460 nm excitation and the third as 405 nm excitation, but the legend describes the left panel as the 460 nm excitation sweep, the middle as the 405 nm sweep, and the right as the excitation sweep measured at 560 nm emission. The authors can reorder the legend to match the figure or reorder the panels so the readers can link each description to the correct graph.

8. Figure 5 panel d, I recommend using a different color than those used in panels b and h to make it easier for the reader to see that the conditions are different.

9. Figure 6 it would be helpful to know the concentration of methionine that was fed to the C. elegans since this could help orient the reader with the observed fluorescence.

10. Figure 6 panel a would help orient the reader by having a sentence regarding what cell type was targeted and whether one would be able to differentiate methionine levels in different parts of the cell using this system.

I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor.

Competing interests

Author declares no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The author declares not using generative AI to come up with new ideas for the review, however it was used to edit the text.

Competing interests

The author declares that they have no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The author declares that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.