Comentarios
Escribir un comentarioNo se han publicado comentarios aún.
Overall assessment:
Hollmann et al. present a study that addresses an enduring mystery in the field of HIV biology: how does HIV target only two copies into the viral particle during viral assembly at the membrane? The authors use biochemistry, negative stain electron microscopy, and cryogenic electron microscopy to show the structural basis for the selection of dimeric copies of the HIV RNA genome by the immature Gag protein during assembly of the virion. This approach provides compelling biophysical evidence for the main claim that RNA packaging by HIV Gag is selective for dimeric species. The author’s system for preparation of smaller, soluble Gag:RNA species will be useful for many labs. This preprint review provides comments aimed to improve readability and boost support for the main claims of the study, detailed in the major and minor points below.
Major points
● The introduction discusses the role of genome dimerization and packaging. A simple infection assay demonstrating that mutation of the dimerization nucleotide tract (as in Figure 2a) abolishes infection would experimentally validate the central claim that genome dimerization is a critical component of infection.
● In the first section of the results (corresponding to Figure 1a, Figure 2a, Figure S3a), dimerization mutants are described that impact assembly. However, it is unclear whether mutant truncates the dimerization tract from 10 nucleotides to four (shortening the ruler) or if the length is maintained but the sequence swapped with GAGA repeats. Adding language to clarify the mutation made and adding discussion of these findings in the results section to explain how the results demonstrate a molecular ruler function would increase credibility.
● In Figure 3c/e/g, the six helical bundle is depicted interacting with density corresponding to RNA. However, the density maps do not show which residues or nucleotides are critical for the contact. A sentence clarifying the limitation of their cryoEM analysis and explaining how the mutations performed in the RNAse activity assay (Figure 3j/k) provide orthogonal support would increase clarity. The authors might consider conducting focused classification of the six-helical bundle and the RNA density from their existing single-particle datasets (Figure S6) to resolve the molecular details of RNA binding.
Minor points:
● The authors use HIV-related and structural biology jargon extensively. While this conveys expertise, it also is a major barrier to clearly understanding the main point of the paper for readers outside specific sub-fields of HIV biology. To make the paper more accessible to an audience outside of the narrow HIV field, the authors could consider simplifying the language and using simpler, shorter sentences and fewer abbreviations.
● Figure 1a: It is difficult to interpret which nucleotides belong to which monomer of the dimer. A color-coded linear diagram or schematic of a single 5’ 350 nt section of the HIV genome would allow the readers to more easily interpret the figure.
● Figure 1a: It is unclear from the diagram in Figure 1 how the dimerization signal is hypothesized to function and which elements were included in the study. Consider adding a gray box to highlight which pieces of the RNA were used in the study.
● Figure 1b-c: The color coding is a little confusing. It looks like the domains should possibly correspond to traces, but upon reading the legend, the colors in b and c are revealed to be disconnected. The authors could consider using non-overlapping color sets between the two panels.
● Figure 1c: The typical void volume for a Superdex 200 10/300 (used for the size exclusion chromatography in Figure 1c) is 8.5-9.5 mL. However, the “insoluble complexes” mentioned in the results appear to be eluting at the “Low MW complex” elution volume (from Figure 1f), suggesting that these assemblies are in fact soluble. The authors might consider adding details about solubility in the results a specific sample label next to each ratio label in the key and labelling each peak more explicitly to help the reader understand the important piece of the trace to be looking at.
● Based on the results text discussing Figure 1c, it seems the authors are trying to convey the presence or absence of RNA. Adding the A260 trace to the main figure would allow readers to interpret the A260 and A280 traces for themselves.
● Figure 1d-e: The inclusion of standards or molecular weight markers would aid in the interpretability of these two figures. The authors could improve the clarity of this figure by indicating the expected MW of the shifted bands.
● Figure 1f: The authors could improve readability of the SEC traces by showing the full legend (truncated on the right).
● Figure 2b/2c show that helical dimer initiation signal (DIS) is sufficient to nucleate Gag assembly into hexameric lattices. However, the single particle cryoEM analysis uses a longer construct. A dataset collected using the minimal DIS might reduce heterogeneity and improve resolution of hexameric lattice reconstructions.
● Figure 3a-c: Figure 3a does not correspond to the figure legend, and looks significantly different from the density map displayed in 3b and 3c, but the significance of those differences is not clear. To improve interpretability of the cryoEM maps, the authors might consider color coding the layers of the gag lattice labelled on the right side of Figure 3c, and coloring the docked atomic models and/or the density maps with the corresponding color (and increasing the transparency of the density map to aid in visualization of the atomic model).
● Figure 3g: It is unclear if this reconstruction is from the sub-volume averaging from the tomography experiment or from a single-particle reconstruction. A clear indication in the text or figure legend would clarify.
● Figure 3j-k. The RNAse protection assays are a nice piece of biochemistry demonstrating that there’s some protection of the RNA driven by interaction with the Gag domain. The authors might consider conducting a gel-shift experiment to show that that the mutations (bulge deletion or G-to-A transitions) also reduce Gag association with the RNA and multimerization.
I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
The authors declare that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.
No se han publicado comentarios aún.