Skip to main content

Write a comment

PREreview of Comparative Meta-Analysis of the Gut Microbiome Between ADHD and Healthy Human Cohorts

Published
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24271430
License
CC BY 4.0

Comparative Meta-Analysis of the Gut Microbiome Between ADHD and Healthy Human Cohorts

Shivangini Singh¥; Anika Bokey¥; Ashish Pathak; Ashvini Chauhan

Microbiomics Laboratory, School of the Environment, Florida A&M University,

Tallahassee, FL-32307, USA

¥These authors contributed equally to this work and share primary authorship

*Corresponding Author: Ashvini Chauhan, ashvini.chauhan@famu.edu

Public review section

Any comments provided in this section will be part of the public review posted for the preprint. We will include a byline listing all contributors to the public review.

Feel free to react or comment on existing comments, e.g. add +1 if you agree with a comment, or post a response if you disagree with a comment or feel more clarity is needed.

If you wish to be named on the public review please add your name here, otherwise we will keep your identity anonymous. Please also add your Email address for full recognition in the final review posted on PREreview.

  1. Aneth David, anethdavid367@gmail.com, 0000-0002-1633-297X

Brief summary of the study - a sentence summarizing the study and general comments that apply across the full paper

The study is very relevant and addresses an important research question. However, framing the study as a meta-analysis is incorrect, as it used samples from only one project, which is okay, but that doesn't make it a meta-analysis. Some interpretations extend beyond what the analyses establish. In addition, the methodology is not sufficiently described, neither is the results section. This compromises the discussion section as well

Major Comments

1. Study design and classification as a meta-analysis

The manuscript is presented as a meta-analysis, although the final analysis includes data from only one project, the American Gut Project (AGP). While the initial search identified 150 studies, only one project met the selection criteria. Analyzing multiple samples from a single project does not, by itself, constitute a meta-analysis of independent studies.

2. Data acquisition, processing, and reproducibility

The methodology does not provide sufficient information to allow the analysis to be independently reproduced. Although the authors identify the databases used and describe metadata screening and taxonomic processing, several important details remain unclear.

In particular, the manuscript should clarify the exact type of data obtained, including whether existing taxonomic abundance tables were analyzed rather than raw sequencing reads. The authors should also explain how the metadata were matched with the taxonomic abundance data, the procedures used for filtering and normalization, and the specific tools and parameters used for downstream analyses.

These details are particularly important because the study relies on previously generated data. We recommend clearly distinguishing between processing performed by the original project and processing undertaken in the present study.

3. Sample selection criteria and potential confounding factors

Location: Section 2.2, lines 159–165; Section 3.1, lines 203–209.

The authors indicate that samples with additional reported health conditions were excluded from the ADHD group, while individuals reporting unhealthy conditions, medications, or symptoms were excluded from the healthy group.

However, it is unclear whether medication exposure was also considered when selecting ADHD samples. Were individuals taking ADHD medication included in the analysis? If medication users were excluded from the healthy group but retained in the ADHD group, how was this potential confounding factor addressed?

4. Core microbiome analysis and interpretation of group differences

Location: Section 2.3, lines 167–173; Section 3.2, lines 226–235; Section 4.1, lines 274–295; Figure 4.

The authors define the core microbiome using prevalence and median abundance thresholds of ≥0.5 and ≥0.001, respectively. However, meeting these criteria does not necessarily demonstrate statistically significant differences between ADHD and healthy cohorts.

Have the authors established whether the identified bacteria differ significantly in prevalence or relative abundance between the two groups? Were differential prevalence or differential abundance analyses performed

5. Age-group classification and interpretation of age-related findings

Location: Section 2.4, lines 175–183; Section 3.1, lines 212–215; Section 3.3, lines 237–250; Section 4.2, lines 297–311.

The age categories used in the analysis require stronger justification, particularly the broad 1–20-year category, which combines individuals at substantially different developmental stages. Given the changes in gut microbial communities during early life, this grouping may obscure biologically meaningful variation.

What was the rationale for selecting these age categories? Would the reported patterns remain consistent with alternative age groupings? Also, did all age categories have the same size?

6. Interpretation of sex-related differences

Location: Section 3.3, lines 241–250; Section 3.4, lines 259–264; Section 4.3, lines 313–332.

The analyses demonstrate differences between sex categories within the ADHD samples; however, they do not establish that these differences are specific to ADHD. Would similar differences also be observed between males and females in the healthy cohort? A comparison across both cohorts, or an analysis examining whether sex-related patterns differ by ADHD status, would help clarify this interpretation.

7. Strength of conclusions and biological interpretation

Location: Section 4.1, lines 282–295; Section 4.2, lines 297–311; Section 4.4, lines 333–347; Section 4.6, lines 362–371.

Some interpretations extend beyond what can be established from the analyses presented. For example, the discussion links differences in core microbiome composition to potential alterations in microbial metabolic or inflammatory functions, although these functions were not directly analyzed.

Similarly, the findings do not establish causal relationships between microbiome composition and ADHD or demonstrate changes in dopamine signaling or other gut–brain mechanisms.

We recommend clearly distinguishing observed taxonomic patterns from biological mechanisms proposed in previous literature. Interpretations concerning microbial function, neurodevelopmental effects, and potential clinical applications should be presented as hypotheses requiring further investigation rather than direct conclusions from the present analysis.

Minor Comments

8. Organization of methodology and results

Location: Section 3.1 should be in the methodology section

9. Clarification of terminology

Location: Abstract, lines 46–52; Section 3.1, lines 201–224.

The authors should distinguish between raw sequencing data, existing taxonomic abundance profiles, and analyses performed on those profiles. The terms gender and sex should also be used consistently and should reflect the information recorded in the source metadata.

10. Reporting of core microbiome results

Location: Section 3.2, lines 226–235; Figure 4.

The presentation of the core microbiome results could be improved by reporting first total ASVs or OTUs, then highlighting some of those core. Also, a complete list of core and unique genera should be shared somewhere, even as supplementary material.

11. Citation needed

Section 4.2, lines 304- 306; section 4.3, lines 321-324; section 4.4, lines 337-339

12. Consistency in statistical reporting

Location: Abstract, lines 56–60; Section 3.4, lines 252–260.

The manuscript should report statistical results consistently across the text, figures, and abstract. For example, the age-related beta-dispersion p-value differs between the abstract (p = 0.792) and the Results section (p = 0.799). These values should be checked and corrected where necessary.

Conflicts of Interest of Reviewers

The reviewers declare no conflicts of interest.

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The authors declare that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.

You can write a comment on this PREreview of Comparative Meta-Analysis of the Gut Microbiome Between ADHD and Healthy Human Cohorts.

Before you start

We will ask you to log in with your ORCID iD. If you don’t have an iD, you can create one.

What is an ORCID iD?

An ORCID iD is a unique identifier that distinguishes you from everyone with the same or similar name.

Start now