Negative Evidence in Forensic Science: Eliminating Versions, Generating New Versions, and Formulating Search Tasks
- Posted
- Server
- Zenodo
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.24188565
Abstract
Relevance. Under incomplete information, when positive evidence is scarce and the cost of error is high, negative evidence — the established absence of an expected trace after a targeted search — becomes increasingly important. Existing research describes mainly its eliminative function; its generative potential and its link to the formulation of search tasks remain outside systematic analysis. Purpose — to describe negative evidence as an independent tool of forensic analysis, to show how it works, and to propose a practical scheme. Methods. The methodological basis comprises an analysis of scholarly literature in forensic science, forensic examination, and decision theory; case analysis of real criminal cases (the Anikó O. case, the Pichushkin case, the Joseph Awe case, the Meredith Kercher case, the Bryan Kohberger case); logical analysis of the structure of inferences from the absence of a trace to the elimination of a version; and comparison with Bayesian confirmation theory and the Analysis of Competing Hypotheses (ACH). Results. Case analysis shows that negative evidence rules out incompatible versions, forces an explanation of why the trace is missing, and turns that explanation into a search task. The key finding concerns the level of elimination: a negative fact removes not the version as a whole but the component that predicted the missing trace. Conditions for correct work and typical errors are described. A sequence of work with negative evidence is proposed and illustrated with a worked example. A system of negative evidence is shown to complement a search-criminalistic profile built on positive evidence. Digital negative evidence ("digital silence") is considered separately. Conclusions. The proposed scheme formalizes work with absence of information and reduces the risk of investigative errors linked to underestimation of negative facts; it applies beyond forensic science — in intelligence analysis, management, and scientific research.