التعليقات
إضافة تعليقلم تُنشر أي تعليقات بعد.
Spatiotemporal biogenesis of thylakoid membranes in the green alga
Chlamydomonas reinhardtii
Thylakoid biogenesis is a central question in photosynthesis research. Understanding how thylakoids are built and how photosynthetic complexes assemble is important for plastid engineering. It also bears on photosystem repair, which reuses much of the same assembly machinery. Earlier work has used angiosperms (e.g., Arabidopsis thaliana, tobacco and barley), cyanobacteria, and the yellow-in-the-dark-1 (y‑1) mutant of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, which cannot make chlorophyll in the dark because the light-independent protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (DPOR) subunit ChlL fails to accumulate. These studies pointed to specialized sites of thylakoid formation, often near the chloroplast envelope or, in cyanobacteria, the plasma membrane. In C. reinhardtii, photosystem synthesis and assembly were further proposed to be concentrated in a “translation zone” (T‑zone) at the periphery of the pyrenoid.
In this study, the authors revisit these questions in C. reinhardtii using a defined genetic system. They deleted the plastid gene chlL, which encodes a subunit of the DPOR, the enzyme that makes chlorophyll in the dark. After several generations in the dark, the mutant dilutes its chlorophyll and thylakoids. Upon illumination, it regenerates both through the light-dependent pathway, giving a controllable time course. The authors followed this process with super-resolution fluorescence microscopy, cryo-FIB/SEM volume imaging, in-cell cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET), in situ ribosome classification, proteomics, and spectroscopy. They report that nascent thylakoids and photosynthetic complexes appear throughout the chloroplast, not only in the T‑zone, challenging a centralized model of biogenesis. They also fluorescently labelled several photosynthetic subunits, including the vesicle-inducing protein in plastids (VIPP1), to follow their localization during greening. Additionally, they describe membranes enriched in F‑ATP synthase in dark-adapted cells, which they term storage membranes parallel to previously described prolamellar bodies, and a stepwise assembly of photosystem supercomplexes beginning with the reaction centers.
To my knowledge, this is the first in-cell cryo-ET time course of thylakoid biogenesis in a eukaryotic alga. The study offers a valuable, quantitative description of thylakoid regeneration. However, as detailed below, several of the central conclusions, in particular the global distribution of thylakoid biogenesis, would benefit from additional support, since nascent thylakoids were already present at the start of the greening time course.
Major comments
1. Distinguishing de novo thylakoid formation from expansion of pre-existing membranes
The central conclusion of the manuscript is that thylakoid biogenesis is “globally distributed and multipolar”. This is an exciting proposal and fully supporting it would require showing where new thylakoids originate. Dark-acclimated ΔchlL cells, however, are not entirely thylakoid-free: they retain fragmented nascent thylakoids at several chloroplast locations (Fig. 1f; Figs. S3, S4). If these residual membranes are already distributed across the chloroplast, their light-induced expansion could appear global even if new synthesis and assembly were more spatially restricted. The authors rightly acknowledge that their data “cannot definitively distinguish pre-existing residual membranes from de novo membrane synthesis”. Because this point is central to the main claim, I would encourage the authors to address it experimentally or to reflect it in the conclusions.
The following experiments could help:
a) Extend and define the dark acclimation. The Methods describe dark maintenance for “more than four rounds” on plates, while the Fig. 1 legend refers to “over four generations”. It would help to state the number of cell divisions. Quantifying residual membranes, chlorophyll, and photosynthetic proteins over extended dark growth (e.g., 6, 8, and 10 generations), and confirming that greening kinetics are unchanged, would show whether a cleaner starting state can be reached.
b) Distinguish new from pre-existing material directly. If residual membranes cannot be eliminated, pulse-chase or photoconvertible labelling would separate newly synthesized from pre-existing protein and reveal where new material is first deposited. Options include SNAP/Halo pulse labels, or Dendra2/mEos fusions converted at the light shift.
If these experiments are not feasible, reframing the conclusion as light-driven expansion of a distributed, pre-existing membrane system would still be a valuable and novel finding.
2. Fluorescence imaging reports protein location rather than sites of synthesis
Following from comment 1, the live-cell imaging (Fig. 3; Figs. S5, S6) shows where photosynthetic proteins are located, but not where they are synthesized or assembled. Its support for decentralized biogenesis is therefore limited. All PsaD-driven Venus fusions are already present in dark-adapted cells and show a similar chloroplast-wide pattern at 0 h and at 1 h (Fig. S6). This observation does not contradict the T-zone model, which concerns the sites of de novo reaction-center synthesis and assembly rather than the steady-state location of photosynthetic proteins. Instead, it suggests that pre-existing material is already dispersed before illumination, consistent with comment 1.
The following would strengthen this part of the study:
a) Tracking newly synthesized protein, using inducible or photoconvertible reporters, ideally including a chloroplast-encoded reaction-center subunit, or psbA mRNA FISH.
b) Imaging at earlier time points (e.g., 5-30 min), with quantitative, non-normalized T‑zone-to-periphery intensity ratios.
c) Adding controls. A negative control would be a non-photosynthetic, stromal Venus fusion expressed from the same promoter. A positive control would be a marker known to be enriched in the T‑zone. A spectrally distinct pyrenoid marker, imaged in the same cells as the reporters, would also help.
Alternatively, the imaging could be presented as evidence of chloroplast-wide accumulation of photosynthetic proteins.
Intermediate comments
3. Statistics and tomogram selection
The quantitative cryo-ET analyses are a strength of the study, and a few changes would make them more robust. Only 3-9 of 31-163 tomograms per condition were segmented, and the wild-type tomograms were chosen to show typical stacks. Analyzing a larger, systematically selected subset would confirm that the trends are representative. It will be good to state the number of biological replicates too.
4. Envelope contacts and budding.
The observed contacts between nascent thylakoids and inner-envelope invaginations are intriguing (Fig. 5E top two rows). However, the conclusion that thylakoids do not bud from the envelope (Page 5, Section “Invagination of chloroplast inner envelope membrane potentially supplies lipids for thylakoid Biogenesis”) could be stated more cautiously, since a difference in lumen density alone does not rule out budding. Comparing contact frequency with a random-placement model would also help show that these contacts occur more often than expected by chance. Alternatively, presenting this model as a hypothesis would suit the current data well.
Minor comments
5. BN-PAGE source data
The authors should consider including the uncropped BN-PAGE gels and immunoblots with molecular-weight markers and a total-protein loading control in the supplementary information, and state the number of biological replicates (to confirm reproducibility). Confirming band assignments, for example with second-dimension SDS-PAGE or additional antibodies such as anti-CP43, anti-CP47 and anti-PsaD, would further strengthen the assembly timeline. It may also help reconcile the earlier detection of reaction centers by 77K fluorescence (1 h) with their appearance by BN-PAGE (4 h).
6. VIPP1 structures in the tomograms
The VIPP1 puncta in Fig. S5 are intriguing. If any were captured in the 1 h tilt series, it would be valuable to look for VIPP1 assemblies (rods, rings, or carpets) or condensate-like densities near nascent thylakoids, for example by template matching with published VIPP1 structures. Even a brief note on whether such structures are seen would enrich the discussion of VIPP1’s role.
7. Confirmation of homoplasmy
The yellow-in-the-dark phenotype and the amplicon shift in both lines (Fig. S1c) strongly suggest that the ΔchlL strains are homoplasmic. A PCR with primers internal to chlL would confirm this formally. It would also help to state which of the two lines was used for the experiments.
8. Ribosome-state assignment
The P-site density in Fig. 6A used to classify translating ribosomes most likely corresponds to tRNA rather than mRNA. In other cryo-EM structures of translating ribosomes, the P-site tRNA is a prominent density, so I read this density as tRNA as well, consistent with the Fig. 6A legend. However, the main text (Page 6, section “Hierarchical synthesis and assembly of photosynthetic complexes during thylakoid biogenesis”) describes it as mRNA. It would be helpful to resolve the discrepancy between the legend and the text.
I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor.
The author declares that they have no competing interests.
The author declares that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.
لم تُنشر أي تعليقات بعد.