الانتقال إلى المحتوى الرئيسي

كتابة تعليق

مراجعة PREreview لA near-ubiquitous plasmid characterises Second Pandemic Yersinia pestis

نُشرت
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24296253
الترخيص
CC BY 4.0

In this article, Seersholm et al. employ a variation-graph based pan-genomic approach to identify the presence of a cryptic plasmid, pTP33, in ancient Y. pestis strains from the second plague pandemic. Previous genomic studies have used ancient DNA data to shed light on the acquisition of Y. pestis virulence-associated plasmid gene content through time; however, cryptic accessory plasmids have been largely neglected due to reliance on hybridization capture enrichment and application of single reference-based mapping strategies. Seersholm et al. generate a substantial new corpus of shotgun data from 110 Y. pestis-positive individuals spanning the second pandemic period. Mapping both these and previously published datasets to a pan-genome spanning the diversity of modern Y. pestis, Y. pseudotuberculosis, and Y. similis assemblies, they find that the cryptic plasmid pTP33 is present in the majority of second pandemic strains but absent in earlier Y. pestis outbreaks and rare among modern Y. pestis. Analyses of pTP33 gene content and homology searches lead the authors to propose that pTP33 is a phage-associated plasmid potentially related to elements in Enterobacterales insect symbionts. Incorporating findings from functional studies, second pandemic transmission dynamics, and the ecology of pTP33-harboring Y. pestis strains today, the authors suggest that pTP33 may have enhanced the capacity of second pandemic Y. pestis strains to infect new insect vectors, potentially including human ectoparasites. The causes underlying the second plague pandemic’s exceptional mortality, particularly in comparison to the less-deadly third pandemic, have been a topic of longstanding debate. Previous evidence suggested limited genetic differentiation between the second pandemic and modern YP lineages; however, the finding of high pTP33 prevalence in the past reopens the possibility that pathogen genomics played a role in this notorious pandemic. While the evidence presented regarding the presence of pTP33 in the newly published shotgun datasets is convincing, addressing several outstanding points would strengthen evidence for the plasmid’s near ubiquity and its possible impact on mortality during the second pandemic.

Major Comments: 

  1. In Figure 4, the authors assess pTP33 presence for strains exceeding 0.1x chromosomal coverage, with an inferred plasmid pTP33 copy number greater than 0.01 considered positive. Given that the mean pTP33 copy number of newly reported shotgun datasets is ~10, the 0.01 copy number detection threshold is quite permissive and several reads mapped could produce a positive call. This makes the absence of pTP33 in ancient strains predating the second pandemic quite noteworthy; however, the reader cannot assess whether the finding of near ubiquity of the plasmid in published second pandemic shotgun/capture strains would be more robust to a more stringent threshold. Including counts of pTP33-mapped reads and inferred copy numbers for published strains in Supplementary Table 2 and computing the proportion of pTP33 positive strains at different thresholds would bolster the robustness of this analysis.

  2. The authors find high sequence similarity between pTP33 from ancient Y. pestis strains, as well as several public short-read metagenomes labelled “Plague chromosomal DNA detected”. Given that some of these seem unlikely sources of Y. pestis infection, it seems possible that the pTP33 in these genomes represents contamination or derives from a related microbial taxon. This raises a concern about potential modern contamination giving rise to spurious pTP33 detection in ancient samples, particularly given the permissive positivity threshold employed. For non-damage repaired libraries, comparing fragment lengths and deamination rates on reads aligning to the chromosome and plasmids of ancient second pandemic strains would provide additional evidence for the ancient authenticity of the recovered fragments.

  3. On page 7, the authors survey insect vectors and rodent hosts of modern Y. pestis strains in which pTP33 is present, and the range of ectoparasite vectors serves as a basis for their hypothesis regarding the plasmid’s role in the epidemiology of the second pandemic. However, the paper only discusses the host range of modern strains from Madagascar lacking the pTP33 plasmid; therefore, it could be that the host range of pTP33 strains from Tuva/Tibet reflects regional ecology rather than differences in vector capacity. Including a comparison of vector/host range in pTP33 present/absent strains from similar geographic regions would strengthen the argument for a role of the plasmid in vector range.

Minor Comments:

  1. This study represents a substantial increase in the number of published plague-positive individuals from the second pandemic period (as highlighted in Figure 1b and the accompanying text). However, only a small proportion of the 110 newly published individuals yielded genomes of sufficient coverage to be included in the remaining analysis (n = 6 with coverage >= 4x included for precise phylogenetic placement, samples with coverage >1x included in plasmid copy number assessment). Breaking down the capture and shotgun data in Figure 1b into high and low coverage strains would help readers to appreciate the sample size upon which subsequent analyses are based.

  2. The first paragraph of the results states that 6 samples with coverage greater than 4X were included in phylogenetic analysis, but in Table 1/Table 4 only four samples exceed 4X coverage. A short explanation reconciling this discrepancy would help readers to understand the thresholds being applied in each analysis.

  3. In Figure 3c and accompanying text, the authors highlight several exceptional outliers with high pTP33 copy number that date to the earlier phases of the second pandemic. However, uneven cross-mapping can inflate mean coverage metrics. Including raw read counts and breadth of coverage values and/or visualizing alignments across the pTP33 genome would help the reader to assess whether these anomalous values are credible cases of extreme copy number variation in the Black Death and early waves of the second pandemic.

  4. In several places, the text references genomic coverage (e.g. on page 7, “Based on presence/absence data of the plasmid across all published ancient shotgun samples with a coverage over 0.1X”), but it is not clear whether this refers to depth or breadth of coverage. In such cases, specifying whether coverage refers to depth or breadth and whether values represent medians or means would clarify precise thresholds being used.

  5. In Figure 3a, provide a key to explain the color coding in the pie charts, which describe the frequency of Yersinia plasmids in modern assemblies used for pangenome variation graph construction.

  6. In Figure 3b, the authors plot plasmid coverage in Y. pestis strains arranged according to second pandemic subclade. Arranging the subclade groups temporally (as in Figure 3c) would make it easier to interpret evidence for pTP33 presence over the course of the second plague pandemic.

I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The authors declare that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.

يمكنك كتابة تعليق على مراجعة PREreview هذه لـ A near-ubiquitous plasmid characterises Second Pandemic Yersinia pestis.

قبل أن تبدأ

سنطلب منك تسجيل الدخول باستخدام ORCID iD الخاص بك. وإذا لم يكن لديك ORCID iD، يمكنك إنشاء واحد.

ما هو معرّف ORCID iD؟

ORCID iD هو معرّف فريد يميّزك عن جميع الأشخاص الذين يحملون الاسم نفسه أو اسمًا مشابهًا.

ابدأ الآن