مراجعة PREreview لMetazoan Orc6 Proteins Evolved Alternative Mechanisms for Association with the ORC Complex: Insights from Drosophila Modeling
- نُشرت
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.24285333
- الترخيص
- CC BY 4.0
Orc6, the only non-AAA+ family protein within the origin recognition complex (ORC), has diverged significantly in function, sequence, and structure across eukaryotes, all while remaining necessary for proper genome maintenance and DNA replication in most species. This preprint investigates several differences between human and fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster) Orc6 (HsOrc6 and DmOrc6, respectively), namely the behavior of the conserved C-terminal α-helix that tethers Orc6 to ORC. Here, the authors postulate that the mechanism of Orc6 association varies substantially between the species: in D. melanogaster, the C-terminal α-helix of DmOrc6 forms a high affinity interaction with DmORC reliant on a sulfur-aromatic interaction between M232 and the highly conserved W228. Meanwhile, HsOrc6 has lower affinity for HsORC, but the authors believe this is compensated for by utilizing a strong nuclear localization sequence (NLS) to increase the local concentration of HsOrc6 in the nucleus to allow for binding. The authors utilize several orthogonal methods to evaluate the effects of specific Orc6 mutations and human-fly Orc6 chimeras on ORC-Orc6 association, genome maintenance, and viability.
While the general claim the authors make about the differences in nuclear localization and conserved regions of the Orc6 C-terminal α-helix are sensible and backed up by the presented data, there are several points of feedback provided regarding the in vivo experiments and mutant Drosophila lines. These aim to strengthen the scientific rigor of the manuscript and raise alternative explanations for conflicting results in the mutant Orc6 experiments. With these considerations, the manuscript could provide insight into the evolution and differing behavior of Orc6 amongst metazoans.
Major comments:
1. MTT assay has appreciably different cell proliferation values between experiments for the same groups (WT, CTR, NA) and appears to use technical triplicates rather than biological replicates (p. 6, 11, Fig. 6B), making it difficult to compare mutants. The authors could carry out additional biological replicates and run all MTT assay trials in the same experiment to account for this and could confirm the authors’ statement that the I239M substitution in HsOrc6 is not detrimental. If these replicates cannot be carried out, the authors could comment on their decision to use technical triplicates.
2. No controls were mentioned for rescue protein expression (p. 9-10 “Methods”, Fig. 4), and the number of transgenic lines used per mutant was not stated. The cassette randomly integrates into the genome, meaning expression/integration of the Orc6 mutant genes may vary between lines. The authors could state the number of transgenic lines per mutant used and confirm there are multiple transgenic lines for each, then quantify both expression rates and protein concentration using RT-qPCR and total GFP fluorescence, respectively, to allow for better one-to-one comparisons between mutants.
3. Numeric per-genotype rescue counts of Orc6 mutants and ratios are not provided (p. 4-6, 10, Fig. 2-3). Instead, the authors state that rescue efficiency ranged from 10-30% and do not state whether this range is an arbitrary cutoff for being rescued or rather was the range of rescue efficiencies seen throughout all mutants. Providing raw rescue counts and expected number of rescues for each mutant along with a chi-squared test would offer a more robust viability comparison between mutants.
4. Some immunoblots are too washed out to distinguish weak signals from background (Fig. 4A: Orc6HsR237A E241A), several panels appear to be oversaturated (Fig. 4A-4C), and others have large imaging differences between the GFP-Orc6 and Orc5 blots (Fig. 4D, 4E). These irregularities may explain the divergence of the ORC association results amongst conditions with similar chromosomal stability (Figs. 4D, 4E, 5B: Orc6HsI239M and Orc6DmM232A). Providing raw TIFF images of the blots or re-running all samples on a single blot could be done to confirm that the imaging conditions did not affect the subjective classification of Orc6 binding to ORC. It is possible that differing expression levels of Orc6 mutants affect ORC expression/stability. An independent loading control such as actin or tubulin could be utilized alongside Orc5 for expression normalization.
5. No count of mitoses observed for each karyotyping condition (p. 4-6, 11, Fig. 5). Adding the total count of mitoses observed for each condition with a chi-squared test of homogeneity can confirm the significance of the differences in chromosome stability between mutants.
6. As some Orc6 mutants share similar results in one assay but differ substantially in others (see comment #4), it may be fair to consider alternate hypotheses to explain the given results. Orc6 has been shown to play an important role in other cellular processes independent of ORC like cytokinesis and chromosome segregation. These ORC-independent functionalities of Orc6 could be affected by the tested mutations, so directly attributing changes in chromosome stability to the ability of Orc6 to bind to ORC may conflate ORC-dependent and -independent Orc6 functionality. Mentioning this possibility in the Discussion could help to explain some of the disparities in the results.
7. Some DmOrc6 point mutation sites tested and the DmOrc6 α11 helix itself sit within the predicted DmOrc6 bipartite NLS. Alterations to the nuclear localization of these mutants may play a role in the ability of Orc6 to associate with ORC by changing the local concentration, as is claimed to be the case with human Orc6. Additionally, most of the mutants tested in Figs. 2-5 lack fluorescent imaging to confirm that nuclear localization of the mutant Orc6 is unaffected. The authors could add the HsOrc6 NLS or another constitutive NLS to the GFP tag to confirm that differences in nuclear localization are not the cause of the mutant phenotypes (or lack thereof) but rather are caused by changes to ORC affinity.
8. While it is evident in Figure 7 that HsOrc6 is strongly localized to the nucleus, DmOrc6 also appears to localize to the nucleus to a large extent. However, neither quantitative nuclear concentration data on Orc6 nor total cell quantity of either Hs/DmOrc6 is provided, clouding whether the strong NLS of HsOrc6 is enough to have HsORC bound to HsOrc6 to a similar extent that DmORC is bound to DmOrc6, or that Orc6 is bound to ORC at all. Nuclear localization can only increase the local Orc6 concentration so much as there is Orc6 to import; the promoter utilized and the amount of Orc6 expressed plays a role as well. There already appears to be a substantial portion of DmOrc6 in the nuclei of both human and Drosophila cells when a non-native inducible promoter is used (although HsOrc6 has greater nuclear partitioning). To resolve whether the NLS or expression levels of Orc6 play a larger role in Orc6 association, the authors could repeat the localization experiment using constructs containing the native orc6 promoter or comment on this as a limitation of the study.
Minor comments:
The authors consistently cite previous published PDB structures of Orc6-bound DmORC, then abruptly switch to investigating the Orc3-Orc6 interaction using an AlphaFold 2 model (p.5), which is unnecessary as the interaction site is visible in the published structures. PAE and pLDDT scores for the AlphaFold model used in the figures are not provided either. It would be appreciated for the authors to provide further reasoning in the discussion of the AlphaFold model for using it over high-resolution published structures, in addition to providing the AlphaFold models utilized (along with pLDDT and PAE data).
The authors tested the M232A mutation of DmOrc6 to demonstrate the importance of the π-interaction between M232 and W228, but an Met to Ala mutation introduces other variables: differences in VDW volume and hydrophobicity between Met and Ala are substantial, which could affect hydrophobic packing beyond the elimination of the S-aromatic interaction (p. 4-5, Fig. 3). To address this, the authors could generate an M232L or M232I mutant in their experiments. This would minimize VDW radius and hydrophobicity differences and more conclusively test the point the authors are attempting to make: that the S-aromatic interaction is critical for DmOrc6-ORC association.
In Fig. 2, it appears that the sequence of Orc6Hs(243)Dm(22) is mistyped. As shown, this mutant includes the terminal 24 residues of DmOrc6, not the 22 expected. An extra two residues may have been added to the front of the Drosophila insertion sequence here. If it is the actual sequence of the protein used, then the naming of the construct could be adjusted.
I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor.
Competing interests
The author declares that they have no competing interests.
Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
The author declares that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.