الانتقال إلى مراجعة PREreview

مراجعة PREreview لA pseudohelicase-centered complex couples assembly-dependent RNA cleavage to poly(UG)ylation

نُشرت
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24269266
الترخيص
CC BY 4.0

Summary

This study provides a mechanistic framework for the CPUG (Cleavage and PolyUGylation) complex involving the RDE-8/NYN-1 nuclease module and MUT-2 polymerase with MUT-15 acting as a central scaffold. Building on recent findings identifying the key players of the predicted pUGasome, the authors use biochemical reconstitution alongside AlphaFold analysis, X-ray crystallography, cryo-EM, and XL-MS to investigate the architecture and biochemical activities of the CPUG complex. They show that the RDE-8/NYN-1 nuclease module is autoinhibited and in the presence of MUT-15, the autoinhibition is relieved. In addition, they characterize MUT-2-mediated poly(UG)ylation and propose mechanisms coordinating RNA cleavage and tailing. Overall, this is a technically strong study that provides important mechanistic insights into the CPUG complex. However, the mechanistic analysis of MUT-15 mediated nuclease activation, particularly the contributions of RNA recruitment and catalytic-site remodeling, remain unclear and additional experiments would further strengthen the manuscript.

Major points:

  1. RNA binding and MUT-15-mediated nuclease activation

The authors propose that MUT-15 may facilitate RDE-8 activation by providing an RNA-binding platform. However, it remains unclear whether MUT-15 is required for RNA recruitment or whether the RDE-8/NYN-1 nuclease module can independently bind RNA. Although RDE-8/NYN-1 lacks the canonical RNA-binding loop found in mammalian Regnases, the S159R mutant restores nuclease activity in the absence of MUT-15, suggesting that the nuclease module can independently engage RNA. Interestingly, the authors also identify positively charged insertions flanking the catalytic cleft, which could potentially contribute to RNA recognition.

To clarify this, the authors could compare the RNA-binding affinities of wild-type and S159R RDE-8/NYN-1, MUT-15/MUT-16, and the assembled CPUG complex using flourescence polarization (FP) as described in Fig S4N. It would also be important to test whether the positively charged insertions contribute to RNA binding. These experiments could help distinguish whether MUT-15 activates RDE-8 primarily by facilitating RNA recruitment.

  1. MD simulations and the mechanism of catalytic activation

The authors propose that MUT-15 activates RDE-8 by promoting conformational changes that allow the catalytic residues to coordinate metal ions. However, the structural evidence for this mechanism remains indirect, as the catalytic center retains its autoinhibited conformation even in the MUT-15-bound cryo-EM structure. The authors acknowledge in the limitations section that further cryo-EM studies in the presence of RNA are needed to probe if substrate-induced allostery is responsible for this result. Further, MD simulations suggest that the activating S159R mutation allows RDE-8 to transiently adopt a catalytically competent conformation, but whether MUT-15 promotes a similar transition remains unclear.

To strengthen conclusions based on MD, it could be beneficial to extend MD simulations to include RNA as well as a comparison to the MUT-15/RDE-8 to examine catalytic center remodeling and metal ions also in the absence and presence of RNA. This may help connect the observed MUT-15-dependent nuclease activation with the proposed mechanism of catalytic-site remodeling.

Minor points:

  1. The authors conclude early in the manuscript that MUT-15 is catalytically inactive, based on its degenerate ATP-binding motifs. However, the ATPase assay in Figure S4O was performed using the MUT-15/MUT-16 complex rather than MUT-15 alone. As such, it remains unclear if MUT-15 lacks ATPase activity or whether its activity is affected by association with MUT-16. Testing MUT-15 independently would help clarify this.

  2. Page 5, lines 94–95. The conclusion that MUT-15 functions as a pseudohelicase seems too strong in the absence of direct experimental evidence addressing its catalytic activity. The authors should consider including this as a potential limitation of the study.

  3. Page 17, lines 423-430. The authors propose that CPUG exists in two mutually exclusive states, which seems somewhat speculative. It is possible that the nuclease module exhibits weaker activity than the polymerase module under the conditions tested perhaps due to the absence of an additional factor, suboptimal buffer conditions, or the choice of RNA substrate. As shown in Figure S5B, the RDE-8CC retains same level of nuclease activity both in the presence and absence of rNTPs. The authors may consider whether the apparent inhibition of nuclease activity in the presence of rNTPs reflects differences in activities of the two modules rather than mutually exclusive cleavage and tailing states. If cleavage is much slower than polymerization the authors could test if pre-incubating RNA with the CPUG complex generates cleavage products before adding rNTPs.

  4. Page 15, lines 398-400. In reactions containing GTP alone (Figure 5A), the authors observe very long RNA products at 5 min, potentially several hundred nucleotides as evidenced by staining, at the top of the gel in the well. A better comparison of tailing efficiencies with different NTPs could be achieved by including time points between 0.5 and 5 minutes. If not, the authors may discuss or explain these observed differences.

  5. Page 4, line 81. The authors should consider providing a clearer rationale for truncating MUT-16. Was this based on Lowe et al. (2025; PMID: 41165327), which suggested that only residues 89–384 adopt secondary structure? Clarifying this would help understand whether the truncation was based on structural considerations or difficulties associated with expressing the full-length protein and whether the excluded regions could affect the interpretation of the results.

  6. Page 11, line 303. The uncleaved RNA in lane 3 (Figure 3A) appears to migrate more slowly compared to other lanes. If true, an account for this apparent size difference could help clarify the interpretation of the results.

I reviewed this preprint as part of the Transparent and Accountable Peer Review training program. This report was written with the support of my research mentor.

Competing interests

The author declares that they have no competing interests.

Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

The author declares that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.