Beyond Visibility: How Do We Make Peer Review Truly Valued?
- Published
هذه الصفحة متاحة باللغة الإنجليزية فقط.
Peer review is essential to how research is evaluated and improved, yet much of this work remains largely invisible and unrecognised in research assessment systems—ultimately shaping the (lack of) incentives for engaging in peer review and aggravating its sustainability crisis. What would it take to change that?
On October 7, 2026, DORA and PREreview teamed up to host an online roundtable event, bringing together diverse voices in the scholarly communications landscape to address this important question and incorporate insights into DORA's Practical Guide for Implementing Responsible Research Assessment in Scholarly Communication. In total, 39 participants joined the discussion moderated by Giovanna Lima (DORA) and Vanessa Fairhurst (PREreview), including invited speakers Daniela Saderi (PREreview), Bernd Pulverer (EMBO), Anna Hatch (HHMI), Pablo Ranea Robles (Universidad de Granada), and Laura Ación (MetaDocencia / Universidad de Buenos Aires-CONICET), who kicked off the conversation by each sharing their dream for the future of peer review (see below).
Laying the ground for community-informed recommendations
Everyone who joined the session was invited to contribute to the open discussion, either verbally, in a dedicated shared notes document, or via the Zoom chat function. The goal of the roundtable was to learn from different experiences, surface barriers and possibilities, and identify where change can happen. Below we share a summary of the main points of reflection, which we hope is merely a starting point for further exploration and collaborative work.
Rewarding peer review efforts
A central theme across the conversation was the need for some form of peer review recognition and reward mechanism, though participants' opinions differed on how to operationalize it. Suggestions varied widely, from financial compensation for all reviewers—especially if peer review is conducted for organizations that can afford it—to targeted support for early-career researchers’ participation, to digital certification for the most-active reviewers, or cooperation and reciprocity systems based on the exchange of credits.
Some noted that the issue of paying for peer-review work is also related to equity and inclusion, as people in under-resourced settings and junior researchers could be impeded from dedicating time to this task without receiving monetary compensation for it. Others raised concerns about this approach favouring for-profit publication models, and the risk of peer review becoming a metrics-driven game where quality is dismissed over quantity.
A discussion point was raised on the feedback loop between the value of peer reviews in the scholarly record as visible, citable outputs, and the possibility of making a case for this activity to be counted for career promotions and receiving compensation. For example, PREreview’s ORCID integration enables peer review contributions to be automatically pushed to the reviewers' public profiles if they opt in to do so, streamlining their consideration into research assessment processes.
Assessing peer review quality
There was a shared interest among attendees in stewarding the quality-control purpose of the peer review process. Emerging ideas included enhancing the constructiveness and rigor of human reviews with the critical and careful use of AI tools, as well as having reports assessed and overseen by multiple stakeholders in order to mitigate individual biases and ensure alignment with shared standards.
Attendees also emphasized the importance of remaining mindful of reputation biases and other ways in which systemic oppressions manifest in academia when assessing review quality. Whilst open peer review identities—reviewers publicly signing their reviews—could help promote higher-quality and more constructive feedback given the inability to anonymously provide low-quality or even harmful feedback, requiring all reviewers to disclose their identities may also have unintended consequences. For example, early career researchers may be reluctant to provide honest feedback if they fear retribution when reviewing more senior peers.
In this context, pseudonymity, via a system such as the one used at PREreview, could provide a useful middle ground, ensuring that reviewers remain accountable to relevant codes of conduct and quality standards whilst adding an element of protection for those most vulnerable.
Aligning incentives, practices, and values
As noted by one of our invited speakers, referee reports can be seen as a service to the manuscript authors. So having mechanisms in place to carry reports across publishing venues would be one way of valuing the work put into producing them, and at the same time, avoiding duplication of labour and contributing to a more sustainable peer review system. Another incentive for participating in peer review is the sense of being engaged in constructive processes: knowing that the venue it is done for valorizes the work, acts on the review, and incorporates it is then very important.
In the spirit of linking peer review practice to incentives, attendees shared experiences on guiding peer-review training participants in selecting a research output to review based on their scientific expertise, curiosity, and the information available for them to provide feedback on.
A key takeaway from the conversation is that ‘how’ we value peer review is fundamentally shaped by who we are and the various contexts in which we live, within the research ecosystem and beyond. The discussion highlighted the tensions between the current reality of the peer review system and the value attributed to scholarly dialogues by the research community at the grassroots level. In order to create a shift towards a system in greater alignment with values of equity, belonging, and recognition, a combination of both cultural change and formal policy change is necessary, according to some participants.
Inclusion, diversity, and ethical considerations
For peer review to be fairly and responsibly accounted for in research assessment, we must first level the playing field for everyone to meaningfully contribute their feedback to research.
Learning resources and support for developing peer-reviewing skills should be provided and encouraged for all researchers, regardless of career level, as the research ecosystem as a whole could benefit from more constructive, accountable evaluation practices. Training in peer review should also include raising awareness of the ethical consequences of reviewing for commercial publication venues that benefit from voluntary work while draining profits from often-times publicly funded research budgets. One way of implementing this perspective in training programs could be focusing on open peer review of preprints and articles published in Diamond Open Access journals. Such training could itself also be more formally recognised via certifications and addition to ORCID profiles for researcher career assessment and progression.
Accessibility, linguistic diversity, epistemic sovereignty, and formative opportunities are also key elements in considerations of equity and inclusion. For-profit publication models and quantitative journal indexing standards also carry colonialist biases, favouring research outputs written in (native) English over other languages and epistemic traditions. When aiming to make peer review activity truly count in research assessment systems, we must avoid creating another commodity or metric that can be used to reproduce historic privileges and power imbalances.
Discussions on responsible research assessment criteria should bear in mind what the choice of publishing venues for peer-review contributions means for equity and cash flow in the research system, e.g., by requiring explicit declarations on where and why researchers or research institutions carry out their peer review activities. However, as mentioned earlier, we should aim for a balance between protecting reviewers, especially early-career researchers and other vulnerable groups, alongside increasing the visibility of peer review activity.
Participants also reflected on how to broaden participation in peer review to those outside of traditional academic settings, such as patient groups, citizen scientists, and others with lived experience. Regarding concrete actions to do this, the main challenge revolves around the need to provide context-specific motivations and incentives. For example, certain professional boards grant educational credits for reviewing articles and remaining an active contributor to the field. These types of incentives could help motivate professionals outside of traditional academic settings to also participate in peer review.
Dreaming big for peer review in responsible research assessment
We would like to end our piece here with how we started our roundtable discussion, with dreams of the future. If we changed how peer-review contributions were valued in research assessment, what would you like to become possible? Dreams our invited speakers envisioned included:
- A system in which peer-review contributions are recognised as part of the scholarly record, and considered alongside publications in decisions about grants, fellowships, and promotions.
- Peer review reports become visible and citable parts of the research discourse, and it becomes standard practice for researchers to cite peer reviews in articles, grant applications, protocols, and other research outputs.
- Thoughtful, constructive feedback should be accessible to all researchers, regardless of career stage, background, or institutional affiliation.
- Broader participation in peer review, including people with lived experience, and a more inclusive reviewer community that reflects diversity in expertise, gender, career stage, and geography.
- Greater recognition of the labor involved and fair compensation for reviewers.
- Ultimately, a world where meaningful evaluation and feedback are valued and sought out, without contributors having to justify why this vital work counts.
Recommended Reading List
CoARA 's working group on recognising peer review: https://www.coara.org/working-groups/wg-recognizing-and-rewarding-peer-review/
Gorelick, D. A. & Clark, A. (2025). Fast & Fair peer review: a pilot study demonstrating feasibility of rapid, high-quality peer review in a biology journal. bioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.03.18.644032
Gorelick, D. & Clark, A. (2026). Expanded implementation of Fast & Fair paid peer review reduces time to first decision without reducing review quality in a biology journal. bioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.06.02.729548
Moles, A., Bonduriansky, R., Bonser, S., Falster, D., Nakagawa, S., Andrew, N., & Lagisz, M. (2026). A transparent universal credit system to incentivize peer review. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 123(19), e2506681123. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.25066811
Naddaf M. (2026). Why paying peer reviewers works, according to a journal's editor-in-chief. Nature, 655(8122), 290–291. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-026-01973-z
This blogpost has been cross-posted with DORA.
Stay connected
If you have something to share, drop us an email at community@prereview.org.
You can follow PREreview updates on Mastodon, BlueSky, LinkedIn, and YouTube. You can also keep up with all the latest news by subscribing to our newsletter and joining our Slack community.