Skip to preprint detailsSkip to PREreviews

PREreviews of Comments on ANSI/NISO Z39.106-2023 - Standard Terminology for Peer Review

2 PREreviews

  1. PREreview by Darkcyan Panda

    Major issues

    • I’d edit your background and conclusion to help the reader understand why the taxonomy is important for the scholarly communication ecosystem in order to motivate your suggestions in the beginning and drive home the impact at the end. I imagine there may be many readers who are…

    Read the PREreview by Darkcyan Panda
  2. PREreview by Janet Catterall

    Does the introduction explain the objective of the research presented in the preprint?
    Yes
    The initial section after the abstract titled 'Background' clearly and concisely outlines the history of the development of standard terminology for peer review models from the 2019 version 2.0 to the…
    Read the PREreview by Janet Catterall